Texas Senate Bill 8 (“Texas Heartbeat Act”)
Frequently asked questions
What is Senate Bill 8?
Senate Bill 8 (SB 8), also known as the “Texas Heartbeat Act” prohibits a physician from performing or inducting termination of a pregnancy once a fetal heartbeat has been detected. This is generally around 5-8 weeks gestational age.
What is the penalty?
Damages are civil in nature, not criminal. Fines can be >$10,000 for each termination of pregnancy that is documented, including covering the costs and attorney’s fees for the person filing the claim [Section 171.208, Subsection (b)].
Who can bring civil action?
Anyone can bring forth civil action and report a violation except an officer or employee of the state or local government entity. A claim must be made within four years of the termination event [Section 171.208, Subsection (a)].
How does this affect Genetic Counselors?
This law not only prohibits termination of pregnancy by a physician but also “aiding and abetting” of the induction or termination of pregnancy [Section 171.208, Subsection (a)]. This applies to anyone even if you do not have knowledge of the final decision of the termination of pregnancy.
In other words, counseling or even intending to counsel that termination of pregnancy is an option, but not actually providing access to a termination of pregnancy could still be seen as aiding and abetting, even if you never follow up to know if termination actually occurred.
What can we do now?
We are currently working with our TSGC lobbyist to understand the nuances of this bill in more detail and have several meetings scheduled. We are also thankful to work with NSGC leadership to provide you with more resources and answers as the path of this bill becomes clearer.
Are there any exceptions?
Yes. Termination of pregnancy, even with fetal heartbeat, can occur if there is a medical emergency that exists for the pregnant woman [Section 171.205, Subsection (b)]. The language does not state the medical emergency of the fetus an exception.
Where can I read the entire bill?
Full text SB8: https://legiscan.com/TX/text/SB8/2021
What is the status of the bill?
As of 10/12/2021, the SB8 bill is in effect. The bill was briefly blocked by a federal judge's temporary injunction on 10/06/2021, but it was reinstated by a federal appeals court on 10/08/2021. Because the appeals process can be lengthy and change quickly, we will only send updates that are deemed important or will have a lasting impact.
What recommendations do you have?
Genetic Counselors are encouraged to speak with their risk management/legal teams for further guidance. If you have received guidance from your institution or practice that you are able to share with your TSGC community please email info@tsgc.org.
Response statements from healthcare organizations
National Society of Genetic Counselors
American Colleges of Obstetricians and Gynecologists
Society for Maternal-Fetal Medicine
American College of Medical Genetics
Resources for additional information and advocacy
GENUINE Collective
An active independent group of genetics professionals in support of reproductive justice. The group is seeking volunteers to help with both national and state-specific efforts. We encourage anyone wishing to become involved in advocacy efforts to join the collective. https://www.genuinecollective.org
NSGC Task Force on Reproductive Freedom, Access and Justice
NSGC recently selected members for the Task Force, which was formed to connect members to support and gather resources to advocate for reproductive freedom, access and justice for our patients. Please check back for a link to the Task Force webpage once it is developed, and watch out for updates from NSGC’s The Advocate. The link to the announcement about the Task Force in Perspectives is here: https://perspectives.nsgc.org/Article/nsgc-task-force-on-reproductive-freedom-access-and-justice-announces-members
NSGC Prenatal SIG
The Prenatal SIG has resources and is also an excellent forum to ask questions about clinical practice with regard to SB8. Consider joining the SIG to stay up-to-date on resources and conversations surrounding this topic. https://www.nsgc.org/Members/Special-Interest-Groups-SIGs/Prenatal-Counseling
additional resources
Organization | Purpose | Target Audience | Webpage |
---|---|---|---|
Abortion Out Loud by Advocates for Youth | Advocacy and story sharing, youth focused, pro choice | Youth, young adults | https://www.advocatesforyouth.org/abortion-out-loud/ |
Abortion Finder | Search engine for abortion providers in the US; resources and information | People seeking abortion | Abortionfinder.org |
Afiya Center | North Texas group serving Black women; part of the "Trus, Respect Access" coalition to help raise funds for low- income individuals | Public (Black women, lower SES) | https://www.theafiyacenter.org/ |
All-Options |
Support talkline, clergy counseling line, workshops for providers |
People making decisions about pregnancy |
https://www.all-options.org/ |
ANSIRH |
National reproductive health research group, maintains a national list of abortion clinics |
Researchers | https://www.ansirh.org/ |
Black Mamas Matter Alliance | Black-women led, focus on improving repro health equity | Policy-makers and public | https://blackmamasmatter.org/values/ |
Center for Reproductive Rights | Global organization of lawyers and advocates | Public | https://reproductiverights.org/get-involved/featured-resources/ |
Collaborative for Reproductive Equity (CORE) | State-based reproductive health research center | Researchers | https://core.wisc.edu/ |
Fund Texas Choice | Provide financial support and resources for those seeking an abortion | People seeking an abortion | https://fundtexaschoice.org/ |
Genuine Collective | Independent group for genetics professionals | Genetic providers | https://www.genuinecollective.org/get-involved-in-ohio |
Guttmacher Insitute | Reproductive freedom (pro-choice), federal and state policies, also maintains a list of abortion clinics | Public | https://www.guttmacher.org/state-policy-resources |
If/When/How |
Lawyers for repro justice, legal helpline, legal defense fund for self-managed abortion | Public | https://www.ifwhenhow.org/ |
NARAL | Reproductive freedom (pro-choice) | Citizens and lawmarkers | https://www.prochoiceamerica.org/ |
National Council of Jewish Women | Gender and social issues impacting all women, inspired by Jewish values | Policy-makers and public | https://www.ncjw.org/work/reproductive-healthcare-access-equity/ |
National Abortion Federation | Reproductive freedom (pro-choice), maintains a list of independent abortion clinics | Public | https://prochoice.org/ |
Plan C | Information for accessing “plan C pills” for a chemical abortion | People seeking an abortion | https://www.plancpills.org/ |
Physicians for Reproductive | Health Trains physicians to be advocates in media, policy, courts | Physicians, medical community | https://prh.org/ |
Religious Coalition for Reproductive Choice | Interfaith, multiracial advocacy organization | Public | https://rcrc.org/ |
Repro Legal Helpline | Legal Resources for self managed termination | Public | https://www.reprolegalhelpline.org/ |
Repro Power of Texas | Advocacy organizations in Texas working to improve access to abortion and public attitudes toward abortion access | Public | http://repropowertx.org/ |
ReproAction | Advocacy org to increase access to abortion | Public, activists, national & state campaigns | https://reproaction.org/ |
SisterSong | Southern-based repro justice collective focused on women of color | Policy-makers and public | https://www.sistersong.net/ |
Texas Freedom Network | Grassroots in Austin of religious and community leaders who support religious freedom, individual liberties and public education | Community leaders, public, policy- makers | https://tfn.org/mission/ |
Texas Policy Evaluation Project (TxPEP) | State-based reproductive health research center | Researchers | https://liberalarts.utexas.edu/txpep/ |
The Center for Reproducive Health Research in the South East (RISE) |
Regional reproductive health research center |
Researchers |
https://rise.emory.edu/ |
Unitarian Universalist Assn | Faith-based campaigns for just, compassionate laws for family planning and repro health | Policy-makers and public | https://www.uua.org/reproductive |